| Jonathan
Pond |
August
12, 1861 to July 1864 |
| Elihu Yale |
July 16, 1864 to October 9,
1865 |
| George
White |
October
9, 1865 to September 5, 1866 |
| William Lincoln |
September 5, 1866 to
December 27, 1869 |
| William
Bowen |
January
5, 1870 to August 30, 1870 |
| Captain Catlin |
Acting Chief |
| Charles
Webster |
Elected
July 7, 1871
Declines July 24, 1871 |
| Captain William Hyde |
Acting Chief |
| Charles
Allen |
December
13, 1872 to February 19, 1879 |
| Charles Webster |
February 1879 to July 1885 |
| Charles
Bollmann |
July 13,
1885 to October 1, 1891 |
| Treadwell Smith |
October 1, 1891 to April 6,
1897 |
| James
W. Wrinn |
June 5,
1897 to November 5, 1904 |
| Henry
D. Cowles |
November 5, 1907 to
December 1912 |
| Phillip
T. Smith |
December
2, 1912 - November 19, 1943 |
| Henry
P. Clark |
1943 to 1952 |
| Howard
O. Young |
1952 to
1955 |
| Francis
V. McManus |
1955 to 1968 |
| James
Ahern |
1968 to
1971 |
| Biagio
DiLieto |
1971 to 1977 |
| Ed
Morrone |
1977 to
1981 |
| William
Farrell |
1981 to 1990 |
| Nicholas
Pastore |
1990 to
1997 |
| Melvin
H. Wearing |
1997 to 2003 |
| Francisco Ortiz, Jr. |
2003 to present |
|